There’s nothing that brings together an outfit quite like an Irish cap. It’s sophisticated, unique, and carries heritage in every stitch. But there are quite a few different styles at your fingertips, including the newsboy cap vs flat cap. So what’s the difference and which is right for you?

The newsboy cap has an eight-panel crown and button top. It originated in early 20th-century Ireland and Britain and, as the name suggests, was worn by newspaper boys, tradesmen, and labourers. The flat cap goes back even further. Farmers and countrymen wore it for its sleek, close-fitting shape and gently curved brim.

Both styles share the same roots in Irish craftsmanship and are typically made from durable tweed or wool - with slight differences in personality. The newsboy cap is a bit more relaxed and expressive, whereas the flat cap feels sharp and understated.

Learn more about the flat cap vs newsboy cap below, but just know there’s room in your wardrobe for both styles. And whether you want one, the other, or one of each, your search ends here at Aran Sweater Market - the #1 choice for authentic Irish caps online.

“I wanted a good quality flat cap and found Aran. My cap came quickly by FedEx directly from Ireland. The shape, fit, construction, and material quality are all top-notch. I will be wearing this cap with pride.” - Dwayne

“Very fast delivery, with tracking and daily status updates. The classic Irish cap I ordered is of impeccable quality, looks great and fits perfectly.” - Axel

“Stylish and the peak of the cap was not too big.” - Katherine

Quick Comparison of the Newsboy Cap vs Flat Cap

Feature	Newsboy Cap	Flat Cap
Origins	Early 20th-century Ireland/UK; popular with newspaper boys and tradesmen.	Older style (centuries earlier) across Ireland/UK; country and city wear.
Crown Construction	Multi-panel (typically 8 pieces) with a button at the top; fuller, rounder crown.	Single-panel or few panels; sleek, low profile that hugs the head.
Brim/Peak	Short brim usually snapped under a looser crown.	Short brim sewn directly to the body; cleaner line.
Silhouette	Roomy, vintage character; adds volume.	Streamlined, tailored; closer fit.
Formality	Casual to smart-casual; expressive look.	Smart-casual to polished; understated.
Seasonality	Autumn/Winter hero; breathable wool works year-round in temperate climates.	Year-round; switch to linen/cotton for Spring/Summer.
Aliases	Newsboy, Gatsby, 8-panel, Baker Boy.	Flat Cap, Paddy Cap, Ivy Cap, Driver Cap.
Face Shape Tips	Balances long or narrow faces with added volume.	Flattering on round/oval faces; keeps proportions neat.
Styling Tips	Works with chunky knits, leather jackets, heritage layers.	Pairs with wool coats, blazers, smart over-shirts.
Fit Guidance	Snug, not tight; allow a touch of room in the crown.	Close fit; brim should sit just above the brow without pinching.

What is a Newsboy Cap?

The newsboy cap is one of Ireland’s most recognisable styles of headwear. It’s also known as a baker boy or eight-panel cap. Whatever you call it, the cap first became popular in the early 1900s, particularly among newspaper sellers, tradesmen, and labourers in Ireland and Britain.

The design features a round, full crown made from eight triangular panels meeting at a button on top. This combination of structure and flexibility made it perfect for everyday wear. The hat was originally made from Donegal tweed or wool, which also made it really warm, durable, and weather-resistant - ideal for Ireland’s cool, damp climate.

A lot has changed over past 100+ years, but the newsboy cap is still worn today for its easy-going charm and vintage character. The fuller crown adds volume and texture to a look, pairing perfectly with chunky knits, coats, or casual jackets.

Unlike more tailored hats, the newsboy has a softer silhouette that flatters most face shapes. This puts forth a confident yet approachable look. You can learn more about the newsboy cap origin in our blog if you’d like - in the meantime, we’ll introduce the other half of our newsboy cap vs flat cap comparison. 

What is a Flat Cap?

The flat cap came around long before the newsboy style - by a few centuries! It’s also known as a driver or ivy cap, and originated in Britain and Ireland as early as the 14th century. It became a wardrobe staple among farmers, tradesmen, and gentlemen alike.

This hat has a more fitted, streamlined appearance than its rounder cousin. It has a smooth, single-panel crown and short, sewn-down brim. It’s simpler, and therefore more versatile. It wears just as well during countryside labour as it does in the hustle and bustle of city life. The tweed or wool construction keeps you warm in all seasons.

When people today see a flat cap, they think understated Irish sophistication. The tailored form gives it a smart, polished quality that complements everything from wool overcoats to casual knitwear.

You can find the best selection of high-quality Irish flat caps right here at Aran Sweater Market, and we have a more thorough overview of the Irish flat cap history in our blog if you’d like to learn more. 

But which style is right for you, between the newsboy cap vs flat cap?

Newsboy Cap vs Flat Cap: Which Style is Right For You?

Our customers constantly ask us about the differences between the flat cap vs newsboy cap, and we get it. They share the same Irish roots, use similar fabrics like Donegal tweed and wool, and lend a touch of timeless style to any outfit.

There are subtle nuances that separate them from one another, though. One is relaxed and full of character, the other sleek and refined. We’ll help you understand which best suits your personality and when to wear each below. 

Design and Fit Differences

The newsboy cap has a fuller, rounder crown made from multiple stitched panels that meet at a central button. This gives it a soft, voluminous shape and a slightly vintage appeal. The brim is loosely attached beneath the crown.

On the other hand, the flat cap has a single, smooth panel that forms a lower profile. It sits closer to the head, offering a more tailored fit. Here, the brim is stitched firmly in place for a sharper line. 

Both styles are structured enough to hold their shape, yet comfortable enough for everyday wear. It just comes down to which resonates with you more! On that note…

Style and Personality Match

The newsboy cap suits someone who likes a relaxed, expressive look. Its fuller shape complements textured clothing. That includes chunky knit sweaters, tweed coats, or denim jackets. You can infuse a bit of personality into laid-back outfits with this style.

In contrast, the flat cap skews more minimalist or classic in terms of style. It pairs naturally with smart outerwear or tailored pieces for a balance between sophistication and subtle charm.

A lot of people find that alternating between the two gives them the flexibility to dress for mood as much as occasion - the newsboy for character, the flat cap for quiet confidence. This is why ultimately, it’s not a matter of choosing between the newsboy cap vs flat cap - you need both!

Seasonal Considerations

The newsboy and flat cap styles are both designed to handle Ireland’s shifting weather. 

Heavier Donegal tweeds and wool blends keep you warm and protected from wind and drizzle in autumn and winter. Lighter linens or cotton-tweed blends keep things breathable without losing structure during spring and/or summer. 

But, the newsboy’s fuller shape provides a little extra insulation on cold days, while the flat cap’s close fit works well year-round - especially when temperatures start to climb. 

There’s Room in Your Wardrobe For Both!

Just like we said in our comparison of the crochet vs knit sweater, it doesn’t have to be a matter of choosing one or the other. The newsboy and flat cap styles both bring something special to your wardrobe, and they suit different settings. Together, they represent the full range of Irish craftsmanship and style.

Whether you’re dressing for a weekend stroll or a smart evening out, there’s an Irish-made cap for the occasion. Explore both styles at Aran Sweater Market, where every piece is crafted in Ireland from genuine tweed!

Discover All Types of Authentic Irish Caps at Aran Sweater Market!

Every Irish tweed cap at Aran Sweater Market tells a story of heritage, craftsmanship, and pride. From traditional Irish flat caps to the classic newsboy style, our collection celebrates Ireland’s long history of weaving and design, crafted with skill passed down through generations.

Why Shop at Aran Sweater Market?

This is the home for authentic Irish craftsmanship. Eachcap in our collection is made in Ireland using genuine Donegal tweed and premium wool, sourced for its warmth, durability, and texture. Every stitch reflects the traditions of local weavers who have perfected their craft over decades.

Whether you choose a newsboy or flat cap, you’re getting a piece of living history that looks as good as it feels and stands the test of time. Unlike mass-produced imitations, our caps are made to last, softening and shaping perfectly to your head with wear.

With a 4.8/5 star rating across 50,000 reviews on Trustpilot, you can rest assured you’re getting the premium garments and quality service you deserve. So, take a look around and see what catches your eye! 

How to Choose the Perfect Fit

Start by measuring your head with a flexible tape just above your ears and eyebrows so you can be sure the cap will fit snugly without feeling tight. Size up slightly if you’re between sizes - natural fibres like wool and tweed will mould comfortably to your shape.

As for style, pick a flat cap for a sharp, tailored look or a newsboy cap for added volume and character. Both pair effortlessly with modern and classic wardrobes alike. You really can’t go wrong with either style! 

Wrapping Up Our Flat Cap vs Newsboy Cap Comparison

We hope this comparison of the newsboy cap vs flat cap has left you feeling totally clear on what each brings to the table and which best suits your preferences. While there is a little overlap and it’s easy to confuse the two, they are distinct enough to be seen as separate styles.

Whether you prefer the fuller crown of the newsboy or the tailored fit of the flat cap, both speak to tradition, craftsmanship, and individuality. And both are available right here at Aran Sweater Market. Find the perfect Irish-made cap today!